Sunday, January 31, 2010

Intent versus Impact

Last week, during his post-State-of-the-Union commentary, a very excited Chris Matthews exclaimed that he forgot President Barack Obama was black for an hour and declared him to be post racial.

While Matthews makes some interesting points about how far we've come as a society in even just a generation, he also unwittingly highlights a key component of White privilege: forgetting race. As White people in a society that accepts, as a default, White as normal and everything else as "other," we can move through our lives without ever thinking about what it means to be White, or how being White affects our immediate sociopolitical environment, or even the effect it has on our day-to-day interactions, how we move through the world.

I used to proudly declare myself "colorblind," wearing it as a badge of honor. As if my forgetting other people's color was some sort of transcendence above racism, dismissing altogether (albeit unknowingly) that racism is systemic, cultural, and institutionalized.

Most of the reactions I've seen to Matthews' comment that night - including his own - are uncritical and supportive. We understood what he meant. Despite his intent, however, his comments reinforced the societal, cultural, institutional notion that white is normal and anything else is other. Even if Matthews meant it as the highest form of compliment to Obama, the Congress, and the nation, the impact of reinforcing institutional racism remains.

As for Obama being post racial, I'm not really sure what Matthews meant by that. But I am pretty sure that Obama, absent of being a public figure, would have a pretty hard time catching a cab on K Street after dark.

No comments: